Hush Street is tracking what’s changing in Mill Basin.
Don’t assume this is just million-dollar homes with private boat docks. That’s Mill Basin’s reputation, and it’s earned — but the neighborhood’s most consequential recent transaction wasn’t a house sale at all. It was a church buying a rare stretch of its own waterfront.
Mill Basin sits on a peninsula jutting into Jamaica Bay, connected to the rest of Brooklyn by Avenue U and ringed on every other side by the Mill Basin/Mill Island inlet. The waterway itself dates to the early 20th century: a bulkhead went in along the shore in the 1890s, and crews dredged a 500-foot-wide, 18-foot channel starting in 1912, later widened to 1,000 feet for seaport development that never fully arrived.
What did arrive, decades later, was luxury housing. Most of the peninsula’s one- and two-family homes date to the late 20th century, many built with private docks and slips directly on the water — waterfront properties here have listed above $1.6 million. The neighborhood’s population shifted from predominantly Italian through the 1980s to predominantly Russian and Israeli in more recent decades.
The strip between Avenue U and the waterway, though, tells a different story: it’s still zoned for heavy industry, a holdover from the seaport ambitions that shaped the channel a century ago. That’s the zoning context behind this Tracker’s biggest story.
Where a claim comes from a broker, developer, or community source rather than independent reporting, we say so.
| Project | Location | Status |
|---|---|---|
| 16065 Strickland Avenue | Strickland Ave., waterfront | Acquired, Plans Unclear |
| 22770 East 65th Street | E. 65th St. | Filed |
| 32794 Mill Avenue | Mill Ave. | Demo Complete |
A Peninsula Where the Real Estate Rarely Turns Over
Mill Basin’s private housing stock barely changes hands for redevelopment — this Tracker found only small-scale infill replacing 1960s houses. What’s actually reshaping the neighborhood is a single institutional purchase of one of its last undeveloped waterfront parcels.
1
6065 Strickland Avenue
A Church Buying Waterfront, Not Selling It
Salvation Church of God currently worships at 5601 Avenue N in neighboring Flatlands. Its purchase of a nearly 3-acre waterfront site here is a genuinely unusual transaction — Brooklyn Eagle’s own coverage framed it as “bucking” a broader trend of religious institutions selling off real estate rather than acquiring more of it.
The site had operated as a vehicle storage and garage facility, sitting in the same heavy-industrial-zoned strip along the waterway that dates to Mill Basin’s early-20th-century seaport ambitions — not the residential, dock-front blocks the neighborhood is best known for.
JLL’s Mike Mazzara, who represented the seller, called it “a rare waterfront parcel” matched with “a buyer committed to long-term community benefit.” Neither the church nor its brokers have disclosed what will actually be built here.
Genuinely Undecided, Not Quietly Decided
This is worth tracking precisely because it’s unresolved: a religious institution controlling nearly 3 acres of a peninsula where waterfront land essentially never comes up for sale, with no filed development plans and no public statement of intent. (One DOB filing now exists — a June 2026 permit legalizing an existing construction fence to clear an ECB violation — but that’s site housekeeping, not a development signal.) Whatever it becomes will likely be one of the largest single land-use decisions Mill Basin sees for years.
Sources: JLL Capital Markets (Jan. 2026); Crain’s New York Business; New York YIMBY
2
2770 East 65th Street
Ordinary Infill, Replacing Ordinary Houses
This is the more typical current pattern here: a mid-century single-family house giving way to a modest multi-unit building, without any rezoning or public controversy attached. The filing lists an unusually large commercial-space figure that this Tracker could not verify against the rest of the permit’s details and has not repeated here as likely a data-entry artifact in the source filing rather than a confirmed fact.
Sources: Marketproof (Oct. 2025)
3
2794 Mill Avenue
Same Filer, Different Architect
The same permit representative, Aharon Machlis, filed both this project and 2770 East 65th Street a few weeks apart in late 2025 — through two different architecture firms, suggesting a local expediter working across multiple small owners rather than one developer assembling a portfolio.
Like its East 65th Street counterpart, this is routine small-scale replacement of aging housing stock, not a rezoning or a larger assemblage — and it’s now moved a step further: the old house is gone, with its full demolition signed off by DOB in December 2025.
Sources: Marketproof (Sept. 2025); NYC DOB NOW: Build Approved Permits (accessed Sept. 2026)
What We’re Watching Next
Kings Plaza, the enclosed regional mall anchoring Mill Basin’s northern edge at Flatbush Avenue and Avenue U, remains under active retail transformation by owner Macerich — new tenants including Coach, PacSun, and Applebee’s are set to open in 2026 — but this Tracker found no confirmed capital construction budget or completion date attached to that leasing activity, so it isn’t included as a full anchor here.
The clearest open question in this Tracker is what the Salvation Church of God actually builds at 6065 Strickland Avenue. No permits have been filed and no plan has been announced; this is the single largest parcel of buildable waterfront land Mill Basin has seen change hands in years.
Mill Basin borders Flatlands to the north, Bergen Beach to the northeast, Marine Park to the southwest, and Floyd Bennett Field/former Barren Island across the water to the southeast. No candidate project from this Tracker’s research was found to genuinely belong to an adjacent neighborhood instead, and Kings Plaza — initially considered during research for Hush Street’s Marine Park Tracker — is confirmed here as Mill Basin’s own, not Marine Park’s, per its own address and most classification sources.
Taken together, these projects describe a neighborhood where private real estate rarely turns over at all — and where the one genuinely open question, a church’s unannounced plans for nearly three acres of waterfront, matters more than anything currently filed with the city.
By Hush Street Editorial Updated Built from city filings and published reporting. About Hush Street





