Hush Street is tracking what’s changing in Bergen Beach.
This isn’t a story about new towers or a rezoning fight. Bergen Beach’s biggest current story is what happens to nearly 92 acres of federal parkland after a 54-year-old family business finally closed its doors.
Bergen Beach sits on a peninsula abutting Jamaica Bay, bordered by Mill Basin and Flatlands to the west, Canarsie and Paerdegat Basin to the northeast. The sub-neighborhood of Georgetown falls within its footprint. Development here stayed sparse for most of the 20th century — a 1960s housing proposal called Harbour Village was rejected outright in 1972 — and the peninsula didn’t substantially build out until the 1980s and ’90s, arriving all at once as one- and two-family homes, many engineered with extra foundation steps in anticipation of ground subsidence on former marshland.
That slow, late build-out is part of why this neighborhood’s housing stock barely turns over today. What is genuinely in motion sits on federal land at the peninsula’s southern edge, where Gateway National Recreation Area has spent the past two years trying to figure out who runs its horse stables next.
Where a claim comes from a federal agency, business owner, or community source rather than independent reporting, we say so.
| Project | Location | Status |
|---|---|---|
| 1Bergen Beach Equestrian Facility | 7000 Shore Pkwy. | Closed, New Operator Unconfirmed |
| 22241 East 74th Street | E. 74th St. | Filed |
A Federal Lease Ran Out Before Anyone Agreed on What’s Next
Bergen Beach’s private housing stock rarely changes hands for redevelopment — this Tracker found only one small infill filing. What’s actually unresolved is public: a National Park Service equestrian lease that expired in 2024, a 2025 search for a new operator, and a family-run stable that closed anyway in 2026.
1
Bergen Beach Equestrian Facility (Jamaica Bay Riding Academy)
A Lease That Ran Out, Then a Search, Then a Closure
The underlying facts here come from a real paper trail, not just a farewell announcement. The academy’s own NPS lease, a 10-year agreement that began January 1, 2015, set annual rent starting at $39,000 plus 20% of gross revenue above $695,000, capped at 120 horses on site — and expired December 31, 2024.
The following year, NPS opened a formal Request for Proposals for a new operator, targeting a lease start “on or after January 1, 2026.” Applicants needed $3 million/$5 million liability insurance, proof of experience running comparable facilities, and a plan to cover a roughly 50-year-old boiler and two 16,000-square-foot roofs the agency described as needing real maintenance investment.
Despite that active search for a successor, the Danza family’s Jamaica Bay Riding Academy — the incumbent operator since 1972 — announced its own closure in May 2026, citing the retirement of its longtime horses rather than the lease process. Between 40 and 50 horses were displaced: roughly 35 went to individual adopters, and 13 went to 13 Hands Equine Rescue in Dutchess County for evaluation and possible sanctuary placement.
Genuinely Unresolved, Not Quietly Decided
No source reviewed for this Tracker confirms whether NPS’s 2025 solicitation actually produced a new operator, or whether the facility sits vacant while that process continues. That’s a real, disclosed gap: nearly 92 acres of leaseable and trail-access federal parkland, previously supporting up to 120 horses and public riding programs since the early 1970s, with its next chapter still an open question as of this Tracker.
Sources: U.S. National Park Service (2014 lease agreement); U.S. National Park Service (2025 Request for Proposals); Brooklyn Paper; Canarsie Courier (Sept. 2026)
2
2241 East 74th Street
Ordinary Replacement, Not a Pattern
This is the only private new-construction filing this Tracker found anywhere in Bergen Beach — a single pre-war townhouse giving way to a two-unit building, with no rezoning or larger assemblage involved. The filing’s source data also listed an improbably large commercial-space figure inconsistent with a 2-story building on this size lot; that figure is not repeated here as an apparent data-entry artifact in the source filing rather than a confirmed fact.
Sources: Marketproof (Aug. 2026)
What We’re Watching Next
The clearest open question in this Tracker is whether NPS has seated a new equestrian operator at 7000 Shore Parkway, or whether the site sits vacant following the 2025 RFP process and the 2026 closure.
Bergen Beach Playground, a $4.8 million NYC Parks reconstruction (new turf field, basketball court, play areas, spray shower) approved by Community Board 18 in 2016, was completed in October 2018 — old news by this Tracker’s current-events standard, but worth naming as the last significant public investment the neighborhood saw before this year’s equestrian-lease story.
Bergen Beach borders Mill Basin and Flatlands to the west, Canarsie to the northeast across Paerdegat Basin, and Jamaica Bay to the south. No candidate project from this Tracker’s research was found to genuinely belong to an adjacent neighborhood’s coverage instead; Hush Street’s Mill Basin and Marine Park Trackers were checked first and neither covers any project included here.
Taken together, this Tracker describes a neighborhood where private construction is nearly absent, and where the one genuinely significant question — what becomes of a federally leased equestrian facility spanning nearly 92 acres of trails and stables — remains open rather than resolved.
By Hush Street Editorial Updated Built from city filings and published reporting. About Hush Street





